25. Goodbye Toby (Season 4, Episode 14)
“There are certain days you know you know you will remember for the rest of your life, and I just have a feeling that today is one of those days.”
Michael’s exuberant send-off of his rival Toby also serves as a high water mark for Andy and Angela’s uncomfortable (and doomed) courtship, the introduction of Michael’s future love interest, and a discovery (by Phyllis) that would pay off down the line. Even crazier, Jan reveals she is pregnant, and Ryan gets arrested for fraud!
Image Source: Bustle